The Slanderous Tale of Sue Robinson's Ghost

 Published in the Kerrville Daily Times on October 24, 2026

The Grave of Sue Robinson in San Antonio, Texas

I’ve said it before in this column: I love a good ghost story. I always have. One of the things that frustrated me as a kid was that Kerr County didn’t have much to offer when it came to tales of the supernatural.

About 10 years ago, I found an out-of-print a book on eBay titled, “The Lore and Legend of The Texas Hill Country,” by William J. Campion, published in 1975. The book is a collection of tall tales, folklore and just a few ghost stories from Bandera, Fredericksburg and the Kerrville area. 

As I’ve grown as a historian and have explored the history behind some of the tales told between the pages of this book, I have found that Campion was more interested in a good tale than he was with accuracy. Such is the case with the tale of Sue Robinson’s ghost.

According to Campion, the banks of Johnson Creek west of Ingram, near the Henderson Branch Road, are haunted with an eerie, pale blue ghost light. The light is reported to be the ghost of Robinson, searching for her lost infant. Campion goes on to allege that the house where Robinson lived with her parents is often on the real estate market and “no one has been able to live in the house very long” due to being haunted by the ghost.

Campion presented two versions of the story. One version states that Robinson was a “good looking girl who naturally attracted men” and “attracted one a little bit too much and bore a child out of wedlock.” The father of the child refused to marry Robinson and refused to have anything to do with her or the child.

Robinson became “desparate and exasperated,” killed her child and buried it near the barn on the family farm. She was filled with remorse after killing her child and turned herself into the law. As a result Robinson was tried and convicted for first-degree murder and was sentenced to death.

Campion attributes the other version to Lena Tullis, who was a historian, real estate agent and society columnist for The Kerrville Daily Times in the 1950s. Tullis claimed she had known the “distraught mother” for many years and said that Robinson had been a local school teacher and that having a child out of wedlock had caused her to lose her job.

Robinson’s child died shortly after being born, and the death was investigated. It was ruled that the child died of natural causes.

Tullis said that even though she was innocent, many of her “cruel neighbors” believed she killed the child. The story ends that many years after her child died, Robinson returned to teaching and died shortly after returning to the job.

Both stories end the same — after Robinson’s death, a mysterious light began to appear on the creek near the family property and that residents, borrowing from the La Llorona legends, attributed the light to Robinson, forever cursed to search for her dead child.

I grew up in Ingram and had never heard the story of a ghost light anywhere out there, so of course I do what history geeks do — I started to dig into local history.

First, I wanted to find out if there ever was a school teacher named Sue Robinson who lived in Ingram and, secondly, figure out how the story of her ghost evolved.

I discovered that there was a woman named Sue Robinson who once lived in Ingram. She was a former school teacher who was well known to the residents of Ingram. Old timers in the Henderson Branch area of West Kerr County still refer to a hill located between the Henderson Branch Road and the Hill Country Youth Ranch as “Miss Sue’s Hill” or “Sue Robinson’s” hill.

Sue Aydlett Robinson was born in Guadalupe County on Aug. 17, sometime in the 1850s. There is a little confusion regarding what year she was born, which I will explain later. Sue Robinson was one of four daughters born to John Robinson, a native of Scotland, and Eliza Wetzell Robinson, originally from St. Louis, Missouri. The Robinson family moved from Guadalupe County to San Antonio in 1858, where John Robinson worked as a surveyor and ranchman.

Sue Robinson was educated at the Ursuline Convent in San Antonio, a girl’s school in Nashville, Tennessee, and at Mary Baldwin College in Virginia. She worked as a school teacher, but I cannot find any proof that she taught in Kerr County.

As a young woman, Sue Peterson did a lot of traveling. She visited her mother’s family in St. Louis many times, went to Europe more than once and claimed to have visited every country in South America. 

An anecdote her family tells about her is that on one of her trips, she met a young man while on a train ride home to San Antonio. Love blossomed, and they exchanged letters after their meeting. The correspondence led to a proposal of marriage, which Sue Robinson’s father would not allow. He told his daughter that she could never marry a man she had met on a train.

“You have no idea who he is,” her father said. 

“If I can’t marry him, I won’t marry anyone,” she said — and she never did marry.

A favorite place for Sue Robinson to visit was Kerr County. In a story published about her in a 1953 issue of The Kerrville Daily Times, she said she had fond memories of coming to Kerrville with her sisters, Hope Brent and Margaret. They would stay at either the St. Charles Hotel or the Tivy Hotel in Kerrville. She said she and her sisters were very popular, pretty, well dressed and had great times when they visited the Hill Country. It must have been those good memories that caused her to settle here later in life.

After the death of her father in 1891, Sue Robinson and her mother moved to Ingram. Their first home was at El Gallo (The Rooster) Ranch on the banks of the Guadalupe. A few years later, the women moved to the banks of Johnson Creek, near the Henderson Branch, where they built a “Pretty farmhouse that was yellow with white trim.”

Sue Robinson was mentioned several times in the local papers. From 1910 until sometime in the 1930s, she placed frequent classified ads warning would-be poachers that hunting was not allowed on her property. She was also known as a generous person who would help hobos who would show up on her porch during the depression, paid the tuition so her nieces and nephews could attend private school and even paid for a neighbor’s appendectomy.

It’s the articles that appeared about her birthday in the mid to late 1950s that caused me to giggle. In 1953, she claimed she was born in 1863, saying “Some of my younger relatives say that I am only 98, but I know that I was born Aug. 17, 1853, for I was there.”  

In 1955, she claimed to be 102; in 1956, she claimed to be 101; in 1957, she was 102 again. Her obituary in 1959 had her age as 110. She is buried in Mission Burial Park in San Antonio, with a headstone giving 1857 as her birth year.

A newspaper article from 1959 announcing the
death of Sue Robinson. The article lists her 
age as 110 years old and a lifelong resident of 
Kerr County. Both statements are false.



There is nothing in Sue Robinson’s life story that gives any credence to the ghost story, and I can’t imagine what inspired it. She didn’t come to Kerr County until she was in her mid to late 30s, and I don’t believe she ever taught here. She seemed to be respected by the community, and she lived to a very ripe old age — regardless of which birth date is the correct one.

Only her name and profession bear any resemblance to the legend.

After her death, her family gave her (supposedly haunted) house to the Henderson family, who moved it onto their neighboring ranch.

A friend who lives near where Robinson once lived said he’s never seen a ghost light in the area. I would love to hear from anyone who has seen the ghost light.

If it is “Miss Sue” haunting the banks of Johnson Creek, she’s most likely looking for poachers on her land.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ace Reid and His Cowpokes

Memories of the Raleigh House: Restaurant owner found joy in sharing her recipes

Former slave remembered as happy, hardworking businessman